28 January 2007

Award for Ridiculing A Country









The job ridiculing a country can pay handsomely. More than that, you can even get a trophy of an international commendation. So far, a Golden Globe award, that is. We will still wait and see about Oscar.

This may not work for everyone though. But, at least, it works for Borat Sagdiyev, or, to be precise, Sacha Baron Cohen. Movie goers from all over the world must have all known him by now. Some may laugh out loud just by remembering Borat’s journalistic 'mockumentary' in America.

Sacha successfully badmouthed a sovereign country, Kazakhstan, down to the lowest level four screenwriters could possibly imagined. It was about a full portrayal of such backwardness.

The film, Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan released in 2006, hit the world with a very high profit. Sacha is now one of the highly paid actor for his harsh and sarcastic jokes.

This is one movie where Jews are ridiculed badly (throw the Jews down the well) and not one knee-jerk commentators came forward shouting antisemitism. Knowingly, people just laughed---even Jon Stewart of the Comedy Central. Sacha Baron Cohen himself, who also take the role as Ali G in a hilarious British TV comedy, is a Jew and nothing to do with Kazakhstan. The joke is on the Kazakh people, of course.

When President Nursultan Nazarbayev visited President Bush in September 2006, Sacha used it for free advertisement by having a press conference in front of Kazakh Embassy in Washington DC. The Kazakh government even felt the need to launch a tourism campaign to counter the bad image caused by Borat. Though Kazakhstan's reactions divided and tactic changed, it is understandable that in the country people could just run berserk. It is not Kazakhstan the country Sacha representing, said a Kaszakh senior diplomat, but "Boratistan".

Of course, this is no longer news, since time always moves on. Sacha himself is now on a new project, Bruno. People go to theater to see newer movies and, sure, there are plenty of them. All are more civilized.

Unfortunately for the country and the people of Kazakhstan, the news is not yet over. Borat also made it into the more prestigious film festival nomination, the Academy Award, which is due this mid February. The short list of nominees for Oscar includes Borat as a nominee for writing (adapted screen play) category.

Inasmuch that some movie goers considered the Kazakh people need to develop a sense of humor, it seems only fair to kindly spare the country from more of such insulting gag. Borat is surely far more painful than that of the fondly funny, country-mate Crocodile Dundee for Australia.

International relations-wise, I think globalization should not have to also mean a free ride to humiliate a country and get more award for it. Even for a laugh, the dictum should read that if it is too much it is too much. When it is enough already, the category applied now should be 'poor taste'.

3 comments:

Indonesia Anonymus said...

Maybe we should stop thinking that awards such as g0lden gl0be or the 0scars are 'international' awards.

They are Americans, given by American judges to what Americans think are good. (hence B0rat).

It is acknowledged internationally, but does not mean it represents 'international' opinion of what is worthy of an award.

We agree with you that the damage caused by b0rat to Kazakhstan is serious, and to repair a false-image of a country is not an easy job.

Imagine if some western artist decided to do the same to indonesia. Are we ready to counter-attack the way Kazakhstan did?
Or are we going to laugh at ourselves in the cinema?

NB: Excellent blog, by the way. Stumbled upon it from blog-indonesia.com.
Certainly will visit back often.

Agusti Anwar said...

Yes, you are right, we need to stop giving to much credit to those American based awards. The problem is, even if we can, others may not follow suit. Still, these awards a global acclaim.


You correctly understood the point I am making, that is not fair to tarnish the image of a country that bad, just for a laugh.

Thx...

Anonymous said...

On the other hand, the Kazakhs had also taken advantage (or tried to) of "Borat"'s notoriety. In Washington Post's December 16th edition (last year, of course), there was an advertorial article sponsored by the Kazakh's Embassy. The title?

"Who Needs Borat? The Kazakhs President Himself is Here."

Now, THAT'S revenge! kekekekkek...